Our schools are far more than bricks and mortar, providing our students with a safe and healthy environment where they can learn and thrive as our future leaders.
With looming elections, trustees at the Greater Victoria School Board propose preserving Victoria High School for its heritage and amenities, rather than investing in a more affordable, state-of the art facility built to a high environmental standard.
Grumpy Taxpayer$ is shocked that trustees dismissed the $68-million state-of-the-art LEED option to house 1,000 students, to include a $6-million neighbourhood learning centre. Instead, trustees recommended the so-called “seismic upgrade plus enhancements option” at a cost of $73.3 million, to include the neighbourhood learning centre.
How valid is this third set of estimates?
Whatever the cost, the end result will be a facility of inferior quality and lower environmental standards, at an additional capital cost of more than $5.3 million. Of note, operating and maintenance costs for this fixer-upper will be more well into the future.
We urge the province to reject outright the trustees’ recommendation.
While the City of Victoria put Vic High on its heritage registry, it never formally protected the property. There’s no heritage covenant on the property, and it’s neither a provincial nor national historic site.
A last-minute effort by the National Trust for Canada putting Vic High on its Top 10 Endangered Places List came too late in the process to have much sway or credibility with taxpayers. We have no doubt proponents reached out to the trust, a non-accountable NGO, to boost its case.
Construction upgrades are guesstimates. The reserves and inflation allowance using ministry figures has been adjusted upward to $13 million for a new build to allow for escalating construction costs. By comparison, the reserves and inflation allowance is $17 million for the “seismic upgrading-plus option.”
The bottom line — there’s more risk to the taxpayer, since estimating the costs of an upgrade for an old facility is notoriously difficult.
On top of that, maintenance and operating costs will be more in a facility not built completely to high LEED environmental standards. Taxpayers will pay more for such things as heating, ventilation and maintenance during the facility’s shorter life cycle.
Upgrades are just the beginning. Don’t be seduced by the $73.3-million estimate, since local taxpayers might be on the hook for upgrades not considered seismic-related. Understandably, the school board is worried provincial funding will not include high-efficiency windows, repointing the masonry, repairing or replacing failing terracottas, dealing with interior heritage issues and adding various energy-efficiency measures.
So, if the upgrade option proceeds, the budget for these essential improvements might add to the tax burden of local taxpayers.
Vic High is more than bricks and mortar. As expected, students, parents and alumni support preserving the old structure, no matter the cost.
The school’s proud history, however, can be carried on in a wonderful new school, and even enhanced by students and the community.
Grumpy Taxpayer$ urges the province to consider a compromise, the so-called fourth option, which advocates a new school that incorporates elements of the old school, such as large windows and ornate facades.
Our proposal is consistent with the premier’s mandate letter to the education minister and its commitments “to make life more affordable” and “to deliver the services that people count on,” to seismically upgrade more schools in Greater Victoria and to build and upgrade schools in the province.
Demands on education dollar are escalating. Grumpy Taxpayer$ appreciates there are huge demands on the education dollar far beyond a new teachers’ contract, replacing portables and the demands placed on it by the Supreme Court decision on classroom size. Serious external financial pressures, such as another costly forest-fire season or a trade war, are ever present.
Finally, we urge Education Minister Rob Fleming to consider the five-year capital plan just submitted to his ministry: It outlines the need for more than $67 million in seismic upgrades in 10 other School District 61 schools. Those numbers are about to grow significantly because of new seismic standards and testing, according to the board.
In addition, $28.7 million is needed for other capital needs, including a downtown Victoria elementary school.
Prudent funding of a new Vic High will send a message to voters that the province knows the basics of math when it comes to spending public dollars.
Frugality and common sense must rule the day.
Stan Bartlett is chair of the Grumpy Taxpayer$ of Greater Victoria.
